Score: 2

"Wow...."

submission: Why wasn't this BLAMMED

date: October 31, 2007

That was truly...not...anything... I gave you a two because I assume you were going for some sort of meta-flash experience where we really think about what we're doing with our art and our lives. But I'm pretty sure you just did it to goof around.

Thanks anyways!

Score: 10

"Can't...Stop...Watching"

submission: kenya

date: October 31, 2007

I swear, you've made me a zombie to this animation. I leave it looping for hours when I'm not paying attention. You've made me into a shell of a man!!!

But great jobs anyways!

Score: 3

"Spread your creative wings!!!"

submission: Breath of Fire Ragnarok

date: October 31, 2007

Until the end there wasn't much going on there. I would really focus on looking at putting out an interesting concept before you spend your time animating.

Score: 10

"So good it makes me wish it was mine..."

submission: Smile!

date: October 31, 2007

What can I say? Incredible job! Keep making more stuff of this quality!

Score: 8

"I dug it!"

submission: PuzzPinball

date: October 31, 2007

Sometimes the solutions seemed a bit random (it's hard to tell how hard the flipper is going to hit the ball, etc.) but it was pretty addicting. I'll keep playing your stuff.

Score: 10

"SO GOOD!"

submission: What are the Odds?

date: October 26, 2007

PLEASE make another animation like this! The script and style was so cool and unique! C'mon McMuffin!!!

Score: 8

"Fun to watch!"

submission: FFVI: Shadow vs. Sabin

date: October 26, 2007

Yes, it is a sprite, but it was fun to watch. Plus I can watch almost anything with FFVI characters in it and I'll be entertained. Keep 'em comin'!

Score: 2

"I LOVE Shining Force!"

submission: Shining Force 2 : pilot

date: October 26, 2007

But I have no clue what you were going for here. I would focus on honing animation a bit so it doesn't just look like characters and objects flying haphazardly around the screen and work a bit more on creating plots that don't so heavily rely on the pointless mentioning of beating on fat people and smoking.

Score: 10

"Brilliantly Unique/Odd/Creepy"

submission: Salad Fingers

date: October 26, 2007

It's been a few years since I've seen this. The first time I met Salad Fingers was when I was still a film major at University of Michigan and a friend of mine said, "DUDE! You've gotta see this!"

After that, I became a huge David Firth fan. His music, concept art, animation, and dialogue fit perfectly into his three-minute mood pieces. If you're trying to find cohesive plots and big entertaining plot points, go watch an episode of "Everybody Loves Raymond." If you can appreciate an artist at the top of his game taking abstract concepts and emotions and channeling them into Flash, then become a follower of the Firth!